Excuses that will not fly with the Agenzia delle Entrate
You
wouldn't believe it, but I started venturing out last week. I actually
visited some clients and spent time with people, in the flesh, who exist
outside my social bubble! It really was quite a bizarre experience
because the first thing that hit me was that apart from the fist bumping
and/ or deliberate distancing, that the relationship had not changed
one iota. It was business as usual, which I found odd at first because
after everything we have been going through I assumed that maybe that
things would have changed a bit. I am now totally convinced that it will
be business as usual once this phase passes!
So I am going to let life take steps to getting back to normal and move onto important financial matters. This blog is entitled 'Excuses that will not fly' because since tax reporting time is upon us again, I thought I would look at the most common excuses that I have heard over the years when it comes to reporting taxes correctly...and I have heard a few! I also want to cover the Common Reporting Standard again, what it is and why it is very important that you get the tax reporting right every time.
Excuses excuses
I
have to be honest and say that I have heard probably every excuse
possible for not having made tax declarations in Italy, and whilst in
many cases I do actually feel quite sorry for the person, because it is a
genuine mistake mainly due to lack of knowledge, excuses will not fly
with the Agenzia delle Entrate (AdE), no matter what your intentions
were.
So here are the top excuses that the Agenzia delle Entrate do not care about.
So here are the top excuses that the Agenzia delle Entrate do not care about.
1. I didn't know I had to.
This
has to be at No 1 because it is the most common one I have heard over
the years. Needless to say the AdE has no interest in whether you knew
you had to do something or not. It is your responsibility to get
informed, and failure to take the right advice or do the right thing
means you are liable for all back taxes if they catch up with you.
2. I am not a tax resident.
I
have written about this many times in the past. If you are registered
as resident in Italy, i.e. you have registered at the comune and are
registered at the Anagrafe, then you are more than likely, in the eyes
of the AdE, going to be considered fiscally tax resident as well. Just
because you live in another country for more than 183 days per calendar
year and your main work and/or family interest are outside Italy, it
does not matter to the tax authorities. You have registered to say you
are resident and therefore they can legitimately come after you for
taxes.
I
was recently contacted by someone who said that she had been registered
as resident in Italy since 2007, when she bought a house, but the home
had only ever been used as a holiday home (she was informed by the
estate agent that if she registered as resident then she would only have
to pay 2% VAT on the purchase rather than 9%). However, the
registration meant that she was also fiscally tax resident. The tax
authorities have recently contacted her to ask for all back taxes in the
last 5 years on her worldwide incomes, assets and gains.
The only way to resolve this now is to put a case forward to demonstrate than she was UK tax resident and falls under the double taxation treaty. That will likely mean lawyers and accountants needing to get involved and an extensive negotiation with the AdE and the UK tax authorities. In addition, they can legitimately ask for all the taxes to be paid whilst the situation is resolved.
One simple rule to remember is that if you want to simply own a holiday home and have no intention of becoming a fiscal tax resident in Italy then do NOT, under any circumstances, register as resident at your comune!
**A small note here, just to say that because of Brexit a number of Brits asked me about taking residency, pre 31 December 2020 as a way of getting around the travel restrictions imposed by the EU for non-EU citizens: 90 days in 180 day travel in the Schengen area. The answer is very simply that it is not possible unless you want to be on the radar for taxes as well. It is an all or nothing situation!**
The only way to resolve this now is to put a case forward to demonstrate than she was UK tax resident and falls under the double taxation treaty. That will likely mean lawyers and accountants needing to get involved and an extensive negotiation with the AdE and the UK tax authorities. In addition, they can legitimately ask for all the taxes to be paid whilst the situation is resolved.
One simple rule to remember is that if you want to simply own a holiday home and have no intention of becoming a fiscal tax resident in Italy then do NOT, under any circumstances, register as resident at your comune!
**A small note here, just to say that because of Brexit a number of Brits asked me about taking residency, pre 31 December 2020 as a way of getting around the travel restrictions imposed by the EU for non-EU citizens: 90 days in 180 day travel in the Schengen area. The answer is very simply that it is not possible unless you want to be on the radar for taxes as well. It is an all or nothing situation!**
3. I am covered by the double taxation treaty (DTA) between my country and Italy, and therefore considered non-resident.
This
is one that I also hear often and stems from a misunderstanding of the
DTA. The tie-breaker clause in the DTA states that where two states
cannot agree on the residence of an individual then a number of criteria
will be applied to determine the residency of the said person.
This might seem cut and dried, but if you register as resident in Italy but maintain your family/work/social and business interests in another country it DOES NOT mean that you automatically fall under your home country rule. In reality Italy, as any other country, could ask you to pay your taxes for your time registered as resident. You would be expected to pay and then deal with the respective tax authorities to reach a ruling as to exactly where your actual residence lay in those years. The important part to note is that, if asked, you would be expected to pay your outstanding taxes and then claim them back! Better to plan your residency carefully before a permanent move or a simple house purchase.
This might seem cut and dried, but if you register as resident in Italy but maintain your family/work/social and business interests in another country it DOES NOT mean that you automatically fall under your home country rule. In reality Italy, as any other country, could ask you to pay your taxes for your time registered as resident. You would be expected to pay and then deal with the respective tax authorities to reach a ruling as to exactly where your actual residence lay in those years. The important part to note is that, if asked, you would be expected to pay your outstanding taxes and then claim them back! Better to plan your residency carefully before a permanent move or a simple house purchase.
4. My commercialista told me not to declare it.
This
is another well-worn example of getting informed before you decide a
course of action. The simple rule with the commercialista is that
whatever they 'advise' must be written down either in an email or on
headed paper and signed. The excuse that they told you not to do it,
which you later find out not to be correct, will not pass AdE
inspection. In addition, if it isn't written down then you have no come
back against the commercialista if they have advised you incorrectly.
All commercilisati have to hold professional insurance in the case of
them giving bad advise, but no evidence, no claim!
Commercialisti are in general good at what they do, but you may find that your local firm is more knowledgeable about running a local agriturismo business than how to advise 'stranieri' with their overseas tax declaration. I now speak and intermediate with my clients' commercialisti to ensure a) they know what products they are dealing with and b) how they should be declared. Most commercialisti are willing and want to learn and very frequently tell me something I was not aware of either.
Commercialisti are in general good at what they do, but you may find that your local firm is more knowledgeable about running a local agriturismo business than how to advise 'stranieri' with their overseas tax declaration. I now speak and intermediate with my clients' commercialisti to ensure a) they know what products they are dealing with and b) how they should be declared. Most commercialisti are willing and want to learn and very frequently tell me something I was not aware of either.
One
quick rule: If your commercialista tells you that you don't have to
declare something then go and find another one. Everything needs to be
declared in Italy!
5. I pay tax already on my house in the country where it is located. Why I should pay the Italians as well?
I
can't recount how many times I have heard this one and whilst I
understand the feelings around paying taxes in one state and then having
to declare them again in Italy, these are the rules. Property is a
fixed asset, and by fixed I mean physically fixed to the ground (unless
it's a caravan!) and therefore you must, by law, declare the asset and
income from it in the country where it is located, first. Once you have
been through that process you then need to declare it in Italy in the
same way. If there is a double taxation treaty between Italy and the
country in which the property is located, and it covers property
specifically, then you should be able to claim a tax credit for any tax
paid. You will therefore end up only paying tax in Italy at Italian
rates.
I often hear people tell me that their commercialista has said that they cannot deduct expenses in Italy. This is correct. If your property is located in the UK, for example, then you cannot deduct any UK generated expenses 'directly' in your Italian tax return. However, this misses the point that they can still be deducted. You can and should still apply allowable expenses in the UK (in this example). In Italy, you report the UK income generated after UK allowable expenses.
I often hear people tell me that their commercialista has said that they cannot deduct expenses in Italy. This is correct. If your property is located in the UK, for example, then you cannot deduct any UK generated expenses 'directly' in your Italian tax return. However, this misses the point that they can still be deducted. You can and should still apply allowable expenses in the UK (in this example). In Italy, you report the UK income generated after UK allowable expenses.
6. I don't want to declare that for tax in Italy, it was a gift.
This
is one I don't hear so often but it comes up every now and again. You
may have received a gift from someone or received an inheritance as part
of the distribution from an estate and obviously taxes may need to have
been paid in the state where the estate is administered. Once you
receive the money then it needs to be declared in Italy in whatever form
you choose to hold it, annually. The gift/inheritance will not be taxed
again as Italy respects the fact that taxes have already been paid on
the gift/inheritance. Therefore, not declaring the monies you receive
doesn't make any sense and would be merely seen as a deliberate attempt
to hide money from the tax authorities.
7. My 'stranieri' friends have been living in Italy for years and none of them pay tax in Italy.
These
excuses are not in any particular order because if they were then this
one would be nearer the top of the list. It's a common one and makes me
sigh with despair every time I hear it. It is also my favourite!
The chances are that your friends are not doing what they should be doing and it is only a matter of time before they get picked up by the tax authorities. I know there are plenty of people who are living in Italy, and have been for many years, without having made any declaration to the Italian state. I don't think I need to say that this is 100% illegal and is advice that should not be followed!
For EU nationals, taking the risk of hiding under the EU Freedom of movement directive seems to be an option that some are happy to take. They remain resident in their home country but live in Italy all year round. Admittedly, I think they would be hard to find, but then they are not registered in the Italian system, are unable to buy a car or claim on the state for medical or other benefits.
Those people who are registered as resident, but also failing to declare themselves as fiscally tax resident in Italy are in a much more precarious situation and given the recent example, (as highlighted above in excuse No 2), then it is not a position that I would want to be putting myself into.
For non-EU nationals, then it is cut and dried. If you obtain a Permesso di Soggiorno to remain in Italy for over 6 months a year, then you are fiscally tax resident. If you fail to declare your taxes in Italy, and are subsequently contacted by the Agenzia delle Entrate, then you can't say that you weren't warned.
I think that finishes the list of excuses. Clearly it is not a definitive list. I am sure there are more but these are the most frequent that I hear. I hope that they provide you with some direction if you are wondering about what or how to declare in Italy. I have a very simple mantra which I stick to which may also help you:
The chances are that your friends are not doing what they should be doing and it is only a matter of time before they get picked up by the tax authorities. I know there are plenty of people who are living in Italy, and have been for many years, without having made any declaration to the Italian state. I don't think I need to say that this is 100% illegal and is advice that should not be followed!
For EU nationals, taking the risk of hiding under the EU Freedom of movement directive seems to be an option that some are happy to take. They remain resident in their home country but live in Italy all year round. Admittedly, I think they would be hard to find, but then they are not registered in the Italian system, are unable to buy a car or claim on the state for medical or other benefits.
Those people who are registered as resident, but also failing to declare themselves as fiscally tax resident in Italy are in a much more precarious situation and given the recent example, (as highlighted above in excuse No 2), then it is not a position that I would want to be putting myself into.
For non-EU nationals, then it is cut and dried. If you obtain a Permesso di Soggiorno to remain in Italy for over 6 months a year, then you are fiscally tax resident. If you fail to declare your taxes in Italy, and are subsequently contacted by the Agenzia delle Entrate, then you can't say that you weren't warned.
I think that finishes the list of excuses. Clearly it is not a definitive list. I am sure there are more but these are the most frequent that I hear. I hope that they provide you with some direction if you are wondering about what or how to declare in Italy. I have a very simple mantra which I stick to which may also help you:
IF IN DOUBT DECLARE THE ACCOUNT!
|
|
No comments:
Post a Comment